Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Assignment #9: Reform Movements
mre

Date:
Assignment #9: Reform Movements


Step #1: Choose and answer one of the following assignments.  You may use valid and credible websites for your research.  Extra points will be given for students who use and cite primary source documents.  Be sure to use outside information in answering your question.  Write your answer in a post.  Be sure to link the websites you used in your research.


1.  [Chris] Explain the revivals of the Second Great Awakening and their broad cultural implications. Emphasize how the spirit of social reform grew out of individual conversion, and how religious change was linked to the wider democratic movements in American society.

2.  [Ashley] Examine the nature of the nineteenth-century family and its relation to society, stressing particularly how the cult of domesticity and womens separate sphere gave women a specially defined role in society. Examine how some female reformers began to advocate their own rights as well as the betterment of others.

3.  [Breanne] Examine the early womens movement as one of the most important reforms and explain the obstacles it faced. Show the relationship between womens growing activism and the broader reforms of the antebellum era.

4.  [Kelby] Explore the perfectionist and utopian quality of early American culture, as revealed in both the utopian communal experiments and philosophical movements like transcendentalism. Point out the involvement of many writers in reform movements and experiments like Brook Farm.

5.  [Erin] Examine the story of the Mormons. In what way is it an "American" story (individualism, fighting religious persecution, pioneering)? In what ways is it an "un-American" story (others' intolerance, communalism, polygamy)?

6.  [Pat] Analyze one or more of the utopian communities, such as the Shaker communes, New Harmony, Oneida, or Brook Farm. Consider how the success or failure of such efforts should be judged.

7.  [Joanna] Review American works of literature of this time (Thoreau, Alcott, Poe, Hawthorne, and Melville). Find contemporary European authors and works of literature (Dickens, Hugo, and Dumas). Are the American works distinct and unique when compared to the European ones?

8.  [Mitch] Connect Jacksons political battles with the emergence of the second two-party system. Show how Jackson especially appealed to plain people who distrusted eastern bankers and capitalists, while the Whigs grew out of the various groups that disliked Jackson and the Democrats.

9.  [Anna] Explain both the Indian removal and the Texas rebellion as products of the expansionism and land hunger of the time. The emphasis might be on how, in both cases, the U.S. government essentially reacted to local political developments.

10.  [Alexa] Show how the Whigs turned the Democrats own political techniques against them in the log-cabin and hard-cider campaign of 1840.

11.  [Valdir] Contrast the earlier elitist method of selecting presidents (reflected in the four-way election of 1824) with the new, more democratic political methods, including national conventions and noisy popular campaigns.

12.  [Andrew]
Discuss the political machines and the spoils system. Consider the advantages and disadvantages of Jacksons democratic belief that any citizen could hold public office without special qualifications.

13.   [Calisa] Listen to the music of Stephen Foster. Compare it to contemporary European music by Beethoven, Brahms, Verdi, and Wagner. What is the difference and why does that difference exist?

14.  [Dan] Explo
re the British efforts to free slaves in the West Indies. Why was Britain successful in 1833 in ending slavery in the West Indies when it was still going strong in the United States.

15.  [Amber] Discuss the northern debate over the means of ending slavery by contrasting Garrisons radical abolitionism
with the moderate no-expansion position of a politician like Lincoln.

 

Step #2:  Respond to a student'spost.  Add thoughtful questions comments or questions.


Evaluation:  Students will receive 70 points for writing a detailed answer to the topic of their choice and 15 points for asking a question of another student's post and 15 point for an answer to the questions posed by others.



-- Edited by mre at 14:23, 2007-10-28

-- Edited by mre at 14:24, 2007-10-28

__________________
Kelby

Date:

Transcendentalism was a philosophical movement founded by a group of philosophers and writers who rejected traditional religion.  The leader of the movement was Ralph Waldo Emerson.  Emersons original profession was Unitarian minister but he disagreed with the rite of communion and he left the ministry.   The Transcendental movement planted the seeds of idealistic and utopian ideologies in early American culture. The movement created a cultural renaissance in New England and  was fully explained in Emersons work titled Self-Reliance.  Transcendentalism taught that humans are naturally good and that they have to look inward for self-knowledge, self-reliance and the divinity.  The Transcendentalists were against slavery and materialism.  They also questioned the absence of womens rights.  It was a group of intellectuals and many other writers were a part of this reform movement such as Margaret Fuller, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Horace Greeley and Herman Mellville.  The transcendental movement gave way to the establishment of communal living in utopian communities.  One such community was Brook Farm.  Brook Farm was founded in 1841, in West Roxbury, Massachusetts by George Ripley.  It was organized in order to mix intellectualism with farming because farming was close to nature.  This community lasted only a about three years but was the home of some famous writers including Nathanial Hawthorne who was one of the investors.  He eventually was unhappy with the community and ended up writing a novel called The Blithedale Romance which was a criticism of utopianism.

 

 

 

http://www.nps.gov/history/nr/travel/amana/utopia.htm

 

http://www.transcendentalists.com/1emerson.html

 

http://www.vcu.edu/engweb/transcendentalism/ideas/brhistory.html



__________________
Breanne

Date:

3.  [Breanne] Examine the early womens movement as one of the most important reforms and explain the obstacles it faced. Show the relationship between womens growing activism and the broader reforms of the antebellum era.


The early women's movement was one of the most important reforms, and faced many obstacles. Such an obstacle would be when a woman, Abby Kelley, was elected to a previously all-male committee, and the other delegates walked out on her, mainly because she was a woman. Also, many of the attempts at women reforms turned dark. Such as when a mob burned down a hall that had been used by women speaking in public about their own rights. When women spoke in public, they were harshly criticized. They were also told that their sphere was the home. Many textile workers went on strike during this time period. Other women found an outlet for their role as moral guardians by attacking the sexual double standard. The relationship between womens growning activism was linked to the abolistionist reform during the antebellum era. Many of the women who were trying to gain women's rights also petitioned slavery. They had to deal with hostility from consevative clergymen who quoted the Bible. The women had to struggle for 72 years to gain the right to vote and to own their own property.


http://www.uwplatt.edu/news/2005/02/eastwood-to-speak-on-womens-movement.html



Kelby:
Since the transcendentalists disagreed with the absence of women's rights, what did they do to gain them?



__________________
Erin

Date:

5.  [Erin] Examine the story of the Mormons. In what way is it an "American" story (individualism, fighting religious persecution, pioneering)? In what ways is it an "un-American" story (others' intolerance, communalism, polygamy)?
_________________________________________________________________________



     The Mormon religion was founded by Joseph Smith Jr. in the 1830's. He claimed that he had been approached by an angel who gave him the scriptures he later used in the "Book of Morman". When his church was established he and his followers felt persecuted and outcasted by other religious groups in New York. After one of the initial moves westward, Joseph Smith was killed by a group of militia sent out by the government of Illinois to squash a Mormon uprising. Brigham Young then took over the group. To get even further away from the persecuters and to practice their faith peacefully, they decided to move farther westward. The Mormons finally settled down in Salt Lake City. 

     Mormon followers faced what many other religious groups had over the course of American History. All they really wanted was to establish their religion, and to be able to practice it somewhere where people wouldn't persecute them based on their beliefs. Like some other religious groups in history they were persecuted for their religious interpretations. Once they moved westward they were responsible for establishing Salt Lake City, and were some of the first pioneers in that area.

     The reasons that they faced such persecution was due to their interpretations of life. The biggest issue people had with the Mormon religion was their acceptance and even promotion of polygamy. They felt that select Mormon men should take "plural wives". This remained that way until the Edmunds Act of 1882, and until Wilford Woodruff required the dissolution of polygamy and of the entire Mormon political party before Utah could be entered into the Union. The Mormon society of Salt Lake City was also in a sense a communist community. The leaders of the Mormon community controlled many of the aspects about it.

http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/tserve/nineteen/nkeyinfo/nmormon.htm

http://www.factmonster.com/ipka/A0881831.html


Breanne: What kind of role did the Scenca Falls convention play in the womens rights movement?


__________________
Kelby

Date:

Answer to Breannes question:

 

The Transcendentalists saw women as human beings who deserved more ability to become educated and to fulfill their human potential.  They encouraged women to join them and one of those women, Margaret Fuller, founded and edited a quarterly journal called The Dial.  The journal included many articles on womens rights.  With the support and assistance of Horace Greeley another member of the Transcendentalists Margaret Fuller also wrote a book titled Women in the Nineteenth Century in which she defined the rights of women as independent rational human beings.  In addition many male Transcendentalists such as Theodore Parker and Thomas Wentworth Higgenson worked for womens rights.

 

 

Question for Erin:

Erin, What characteristics of the Mormon Community make it a similar to a communist community?



__________________
Alexa

Date:

The whigs endorsed Henry Clays American system. This included the national bank, federally supported internal improvements, and tariff protection for industry. The Democrates wanted freedom from those who legislated morality, religious tyranny, and special privledges. The whigs thought there was enough freedom in the nation. The whigs campaigns included songs, cartoons, barbeques and torchlight parades. The democrats had used these techniques also. The whigs made fun of the democrats nominee Van Buren.


Kelby - How did the people of Brook Farms adapt to their new utopian society?



__________________
mre

Date:

Grades updated 11/4

__________________
Dan S.

Date:

The road leading to Britains final decision to abolish slavery has not one but a couple of factors that determined this outcome.  The key factors in seeing that slavery was abolished in Britain in 1838 are the abolition movements, economic shifts, Imperial competition, slave revolts, and the decrease in the production and profitability of slavery.  Also, while both the U.S. and Britain had made the slave trade illegal 1808 and 1807, respectively, it took longer for the U.S. to abolish slavery for other reasons.   

 

Compared to the abolition movements the primary factor was the slave revolts.  The reason they are is that they deal with the actual slaves themselves.  The slaves revolted as the ideas of independence came to them from the news of political and social change that had resulted from the American and French revolutions.  Highly influential were the revolts in colonies such as the ones in Haiti, where it won independence in 1804, and Jamaica, where 20,000 slaves revolted and were put down in a brutal manner.  These acts by slaves fueled abolitionists and provided with more reason to fight slavery.

 

The First step in abolishing slavery in either the U.S. or Britain began with peoples efforts to raise awareness about it to the general public.  By doing so they obviously gained support and spread the word by: books, prints, posters, pamphlets, rallies, and petitions to the House of Commons.  The official Society for the Abolition of the Slave Trade was organized and formally founded in 1787 but some of its Quaker leaders had been active before that.  Just like in the U.S. there were important and notable people taking part in the campaign of abolition in Britain and had the same arguments as them.  Such names that were known were William Wilberforce, Thomas Clarkson, Ignatius Sancho, and Olaudah Equiano.  The latter two wrote of their experiences as slavery and their works became bestsellers while the former two worked in British politics, Wilberforce being a relentless parliamentarian and Clarkson being a lobbyist.

 

      By the end of the 18th century economics shifts to a world capitalist economy were taking place due to manufacturing and industrialization.  As a result the rapid industrialization and the expansion of British capitalism put plantation slavery and the institution itself in a decline in Britain as they were outgrowing them.  It was becoming more profitable to invest in commerce and industry than in slavery.  Since Britain made the slave trade illegal and pulled out, it greatly hurt the slave trade.  Britain was now turning towards wage labor instead of slavery.

 

As the British government outlawed the slave trade due to the slave revolts, pushing from abolitionists and slaverys lack of importance in the economy it also made sure that no one would try to continue it on the empire.  To do this it put ships in position to enforce the ban and intercept law-breakers which continued up until the 1880s.  It would also benefit Britain if the slave trade stopped for it aided its rival France and this movement gained much support for it was seen as a patriotic war measure.  Lobbying for abolition continued until 1833 when Parliament passed the Slavery Abolition Act which went into effect in 1834 and transferred the status of slaves 6 and older to that of indentured laborers.  However real emancipation came in 1838 when all slaves became officially free when they did away with the indentured status.

 

Lastly the reason that the U.S. maintained slavery for a longer time was that it had established a strong proslavery stance in the Southern states and had created a large-scale internal slave trade between states that was greater than the foreign importation had been.

Question for Alexa:  In what ways or how did the Whigs make fun of Martin Van Buren?

__________________
Chris

Date:

    The revivals of the Second Great Awakening had profound affects throughout the different parts of the U.S. In the New England area the new wave of religious zeal caused many people to respond to social issues such as slavery and temperance and reform those institutions they deemed unjust or immoral. New Yorks Burnt Over District (Lake Ontario to the Adirondack Mountains) produced many Christian denominations such as the Mormons and the Seventh Day Adventists, and with the help of Charles Finney saw a soaring number of converts to the Christian faith. In the west the camp meeting which could draw crowds numbering in the thousands and sometimes tens of thousands of Christian followers, strengthening the resolve of those who attended which included Methodists, Baptists, and Presbyterians in large numbers (which were increasingly getting larger very quickly).


In New England and in other parts of the country the tide of religious fervor began to transform many aspects of society. For one, the individual conversions helped many to see the light and some of those who did, because of moral obligation, actively tried to reform certain aspects of society and followed in the footsteps of reformers like Dorathea Dix with the prison and asylum reform and Lyman Beecher with the temperance movement. Many of those like Lyman Beecher who were converted, said that it was a very moving and powerful experience which actually inspired them to do the lords work and become involved in these moral reform movements. One of these such movements was the abolitionist movement which as more and more people began picking up their bibles and looking deeper into this issue that would soon split the largely because of this huge resounding issue, amplified by the events of this period.



__________________
Breanne

Date:

Breanne: What kind of role did the Seneca Falls convention play in the womens rights movement? 

The Seneca Falls convention allowed the women from the womens rights movement allowed them to create their own declaration, modeled after the Declaration of Independence, called the Declaration of Sentiments. In this document, women asked for the right to vote, and the right to control their own property.



__________________
Erin

Date:

Question for Erin:

Erin, What characteristics of the Mormon Community make it a similar to a communist community?

The Morman leaders controlled the politics of the Salt Lake City settlement. It remained that way until the government refused to let Utah join the union unless the Mormon party had been disbanded.

If that doesn't answer your question let me know.



__________________
Anna :)

Date:

9. [Anna] Explain both the Indian removal and the Texas rebellion as products of the expansionism and land hunger of the time. The emphasis might be on how, in both cases, the U.S. government essentially reacted to local political developments.

The Indian Removal and the Texas Rebellion were both attempts to push a group of people out of a desired area, making it possible for land expansion and following the Manifest Destiny slogan. The Indian Removal was supported heavily by president Jackson and included the removal of the five civilized Native American tribes that inhabited land in the eastern part of the United States. These tribes included the Cherokee, Creek, Chickasaw, Choctaw, and the Seminole. The removal was carried out by forcing these tribes to move further and further west. The purpose of the Indian Removal was to clear out Native American lands to set up American communities and expand across the North American continent. In the Texas Rebellion, Texans, after being defeated in the Battle at the Alamo and the Battle of Goliad, put up a fight in the Battle of San Jacinto and eventually won their independence from Mexico though annexation. The Mexicans wanted a more populated country and promised land if people came to live in Mexico. The only catch was that people coming to live in Mexico had to convert to Catholicism, and speak the Spanish language. The Texans were fighting for their independence from Mexico after refusing to accommodate to these requests. In the Indian Removal, Native Americans were forced west so Americans could have more room for land expansion. In the Texas Rebellion, Mexicans were fighting the Texans so they could keep Texas as territory under Mexican control, which equals more land for Mexico. These two events both were results of the desire for land expansion in North America during the nineteenth century.

Resources:
o http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h306.html
o My APUSH Textbook




__________________
Anna :)

Date:

Question to Erin: Who was Wilford Woodruff and what exactly is polygamy?

__________________
Anonymous

Date:

Anna :) wrote:

Question to Erin: Who was Wilford Woodruff and what exactly is polygamy?




Wilford Woodruff was the 4th president of "The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints" (The Mormons). He published a Manifesto that dissolved the Mormon party so that Utah could be entered into the Union.

Polygamy, is when a man marries more than one wife at a time.



__________________
Erin

Date:

Anonymous wrote:

Anna :) wrote:

Question to Erin: Who was Wilford Woodruff and what exactly is polygamy?




Wilford Woodruff was the 4th president of "The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints" (The Mormons). He published a Manifesto that dissolved the Mormon party so that Utah could be entered into the Union.

Polygamy, is when a man marries more than one wife at a time.



Ooops that was me....sorry biggrin



__________________
Joanna

Date:

  1. [Joanna] Review American works of literature of this time (Thoreau, Alcott, Poe, Hawthorne, and Melville). Find contemporary European authors and works of literature (Dickens, Hugo, and Dumas). Are the American works distinct and unique when compared to the European ones?

 

 

American works are not that distinct and unique when compared to the European ones. It seems to me that all these authors worked off each other.

 

Henry David Thoreau wrote in a simplistic, free thinking, liberal way. He also believed in self reliance and tried to find the truth in himself. Thoreau is considered the godfather of the hippie movement.

 

Amos Bronson Alcott was a noted educator and social reformer. He was a transcendentalist and an utopian.  Transcendentalism is a literary and philosophical movement asserting the existence of an ideal spiritual reality. An Utopian is someone who wants to live in idealized perfection. Louisa May Alcott is a novelist who was also and utopian and a transcendentalist who wrote the famous novel Little Woman.

 

Edgar Allan Poe had a unique writing style. He focused on fear and guilt and the popular pseudosciences phrenology and physiognomy. He basically wrote about practices or methods considered without a scientific foundation. Phrenology is the study of the shape of the skull, it was once used to show mental capacity and a persons character. Physiognomy is the art of judging human character based on facial appearance.  Poe was also greatly influenced by Charles Dickens who was from Europe.

 

Nathaniel Hawthorne used the literary technique romanticism, in his writings. Romanticism was started in Western Europe and it was basically an artistic way of writing.  Herman Melville was influenced by Hawthorne. He wrote in depth and used gothic grimaces every so often. Basically these two American authors worked and were influence from European literary techniques.

 

 

Charles Dickens is a very popular European author, who influenced both American and European authors. Dickens writes in a florid poetic way with a comic touch. He also writes in a sarcastic way towards the wealthy during his time. Dickens also mixed fantasy and realism perfectly, to add a nice blend in his work.

 

Victor Hugo also used the romantic style of writing. Alexandre Dumas wrote historical novels that contained adventure.

 

In conclusion American authors were influenced by Charles Dickens and romanticism that both originated in Europe. Although American authors such as Thoreau did write quite differently when compared with other authors.

 www. wikipedia.com
www.sparknotes.com
 My textbook



__________________
Joanna

Date:

question to Anna : What type of  Americans were supposed to dwell in those set up communities?

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard