Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Assignment #11: Manifest Destiny
mre

Date:
Assignment #11: Manifest Destiny


Homework (November 5-November 9)

Monday
: Roundtable Video (Westward Migration), Chapter 13 Pre-Test, Wiki Review 13-1
Tuesday: Wiki Review 13-2, Forum Primary Source #12
Wednesday
: Wiki Review 13-3, Primary Source #13

Thursday
: Wiki Review, 13-4, Zinn, Howard.  Peoples History of the United States (abridged teaching edition).  Chapter 8 We Take Nothing By Conquest, Thank God.  Assignment:  Who were the opponents to the war?  How did they manifest (in word and deed) their opposition to war?  To what degree were their tactics effective?  How could they have been more effective (what were the obstacles in the way of their success)?

Friday
: Wiki Review 13-5, Chapter 13 Post Test, DBQ: Identify the factors that led to westward migration after 1820. How did the rising importance of the West influence the social, economic and political trends of the rest of the country in the antebellum period? [Source: http://historyteacher.net/USProjects/DBQs2002/DBQ2002_WestwardMigration.htm]

Lab Assignments:

Monday:
Students will examine the PBS site, The West, to examine the history and stories of Americas political, economic and social history of westward expansion.  Students will examine the information on the site and create a top ten list of most historically important people, events or places.  They will explain the historical significance of each in a PowerPoint presentation.  http://www.pbs.org/weta/thewest/

Tuesday: Students will examine the PBS site: The US/Mexican War (1846-1848) and complete the following assignment: Imagine yourself as a museum curator given the task of creating an series of exhibit halls chronicling the westward expansion of the US.  One of your major tasks is to focus on the US/Mexican War.  Using the site below, explain how you will design your exhibit, what is in it, and why you have chosen each specific object.  http://www.pbs.org/kera/usmexicanwar/index_flash.html

Wednesday:  Students will examine the factors that influenced one of the largest population shifts in our countrys history by completing the tasks of the Go West webquest.  Students will specifically work in groups to convince family members and others to move to the west and risk their very survival for the dreams of fortune and freedom.  http://bkgoldberg.tripod.com/gowest/


Alternative Assignment: Answer the following DBQ http://spartans.sstx.org/~ssallee/Apfornet/DBQpractice.html

Friday: Students will examine the letters, diaries and documents associated with westward expansion with a particular focus on Mexican Americans and Native Americans.  Students will use the materials available from the Digital History website for their research materials.  Using the tools of historiography, students will make educated inferences concerning the events and issues of the 1840s.   http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/mexican_voices/mexican_voices.cfm and http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/native_voices/native_voices.cfm

-- Edited by mre at 12:24, 2007-11-07

__________________
ashley baldo

Date:

I, Ashley Baldo, am now fulfilling my dream of becoming a museum curatorhahaha

 

First a short description on the events leading to the Mexican war, [movie]

  1. Mexico invites American settlers to help colonize Texas, as long as they follow the rules of becoming Catholic, and no slaves.
  2. The Americans bring slaves and dont follow rules, then begin getting greedy for Mexican land.
  3. Mexico and America then go to war over the hostilities being created.
 

Short Biography on General Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna [plaque]

  1. Born 1794
  2. Supported Mexican independence in 1821
  3. As the war started he was in exile
  4. He came back, staged a coup, and instated himself president of Mexico
  5. He failed in trying to win the war, and was exiled again, this time to Columbia
 

Short Biography on Sam Houston[plaque]

 

Model of the Alamo[1/2 size, so its really big =)]

 

Description of the Battle of San Jacinto [reenactment with actors]

                        (get visitors involved in reenactment)

 

Penny papers that tell of that time period in glass cases to be displayed.

         Copies of the papers describing the battle the visitors were just in to be handed out.

 As they leave welcome them to the Lone Star Republic, because it is not a state until June 16, 1845.

__________________
Breanne

Date:

In my exhibit, I would put: 
  • One of Stephen F. Austins suits, from when he studied law with former U.S. Congressman Joseph Hawkins, and successfully helped the Mexican independence movement. I would put this artifact at the beginning of the exhibit.
 
  • Since General Antonio López de Santa Anna was a military leader, I would put one of his weapons he used to fight in my exhibit in a case towards the end of the exhibit.
  
  • Pictures from the aftermath of the war, because they depict what happened to the survivors of the war. I would put these pictures all along the walls of the museum. I would use pictures from the Graham Pilecki Collection.
 
  • I would also put newspaper articles from the time of the war in my museum. These would help people understand what happened to the economy during the Mexican War.
  
  • Another interesting artifact to use in my museum would be pictures that people drew of the battles while they were taking place.
 
  • I would put the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in my museum as the end artifact because my museum was created for the Mexican/US war, it would be fit to put the document that ended the war in my exhibit.
   As an interactive part of the exhibit, I would set up a movie on the Alamo, and some other movies about the main people who fought in the battles. This would be set up at the beginning of the exhibit because it would provide all the background information people would need before viewing other artifacts in the museum.

__________________
Alexa

Date:

tuesday - mexico exhibit.


Newspaper articles on Mexico sections of local, national, and international news, which were taken from other national or international newspapers. there were letters written by the public to the editors, informing about or commenting on the news and editorials. there was the editorial page.

 

Newspaper articles on United States - emerging penny press in the United States with an excellent opportunity to demonstrate news enterprise. penny press newspapers made expensive, elaborate arrangements to have their reports carried back to the United States. combining pony express, steamships, railroads, and the fledgling telegraph, the press established a two-thousand mile communications link that repeatedly beat military couriers and the U.S. mail with the Mexico news.

 

USA Flag Large replica of the United States Flag. Colors are red white and blue. In the section of blue there were multiple white stars.

 

Mexican Flag Large replica of the United States Flag. Colors are green white and red and in the middle of the white part of the flag was an eagle design.

 

Paintings of Mexican War

 

Map of Mexico

 

Map of United States

 

Biographies.

 

Of Abraham Lincoln (USA) Freshman Whig congressman. He became a vocal critic for President James K. Polk.

 

Of Stephen F. Austin (USA)   was imprisoned by Mexican military soldiers while attempting to play mediator. He held military command shortly before he returned to the United States for financial support.

 Of Hernan Cortez (Mexico) He conquered Mexico. He renamed the Indian Capital Tenochtitlan, Mexico City.

__________________
Dan S.

Date:

U.S. - MexicanWarMuseum

Curator - Daniel Steliga

The museum will be split into two major parts each representing a different point of view. The Rooms and exhibits themselves will be split in half, each side representing either the U.S. or Mexican point of view. The museum will also be decorated accordingly showing styles of the Americans and Mexicans. Primary source documents will be implemented all throughout the museum as well, when possible, for interested people and to show actual evidence and real opinions of people of the time.  Throughout the museum in each exhibit there will be a continuing and interactive timeline to help visitors put the situation in context both in the Americas and globally at the time.

 What is to be included in my museum:

1. An introductory exhibit on both countries and their respective economic, political, and geographical issues of the time in context. This will include maps before and after the war with details on the borders of the countries.

2. An exhibit showcasing the presidents and their positions, policies, and beliefs. There will be primary documents from both with an option to listen to it in audio version as retold by an actor. There will also be a video of a debate between the two also done by well-trained actors. To help the visitors get a good idea of what the presidents looked like their will be the most accurate representative wax life-size figures of each shown.

3. Another exhibit will be on the period before the war and topics that led to the war. Such that will be shown and elaborated on are: Manifest Destiny, existing trade routes, and claims to land, borders, and boundaries.

4. The next exhibit and biggest room will be highlighting the War itself. One section will be dedicated to each sides army and statistics regarding each along with explaining how each worked and what it would be like to be in each. It will have a section that will show what life was like for the people living close to and on the borderlands and what their opinions were.  In another section it will show many of the battles that took place, especially important key battles, with comments from people who wrote about them at the time. The last section will show the wars resolution and the provisions of the Treaty of Guadalupe.

5.  The last part of the museum will show the aftermath of the war including its effects on both countries and address issues that were raised during the time.

5. At the end of the tour will be a food court continuing the divisive state of the museum by having a Mexican and American themed restaurant, souvenir shop, and restrooms.



__________________
Erin

Date:

Can I email you my stuff for the exhibit?? Its a picture so it would be easier.

__________________
Kelby

Date:

List of Items for MexicanAmericanWarMuseum

 

  1. Life like mannequins that present a debate between President Polk and Abraham Lincoln about the differing opinions between the President and the Whig Party regarding the War and about President Polks initial account of the events that led to the war.

 

  1. Brief movie presentation of Battle re-enactments.

 

  1. Maps showing movement of American troops during the Mexican American War.

 

  1. Life like statues of important figures involved in the war such as General Zachary Taylor.

 

  1. Uniforms worn by soldiers from both sides of the Mexican American War.

 

  1. Weapons used during the Mexican American War era.

 

  1. Miniature displays of some of the battles of the war, such as the Battle of Veracruz and the Battle of Santa Ana.  The display would include miniature figures, weapons and terrain.

 

  1. Mexican American War documents such as :

Speeches

Proclamations

Treaties

Battle reports

Diaries or writings of soldiers from both sides.

      

  1. Roster of veterans of regular and volunteer groups of the war.

 

  1. Mexican Era Artifacts:

Pipes and other smoking materials

Plates , cups and eating utensils.

Drinking canteen

Saddle

Musket balls

            Medical supplies   



__________________
Kelby

Date:

Where's the Zinn homework assignment?

__________________
Joanna

Date:

Tuesday's Assignment

My exhibit would be broken into seven sections. Each of these sections would have pictures and specific information pertaining to that title. I would try to recreate this time period. People who visit this exhibit get a sense of what actually happened. I would use newspaper articles from that time frame so you can read a direct perspective from the folks that lived during this time period. I would finish the job with adding artifacts from the war, such as guns or mugs, some sort of visual.

 

 

  1. Cause : Background

·        This section would basically describe the causes of the war.

 

  1. US view

·        This section would just state Americas opinion on the war and explain why this country thought its actions were just.

 

  1. Mexico View

·        This section of my museum would state Mexicos view on the war. It would also explain Mexicos position, and why it their actions were just.

  1. Important People (leaders)

·        This part of my exhibit would just expose the people in charge, or someone who had an impact. Each person would have a picture, a small bio, and why they were significant at this time.

 

 

United States Mexico

Stephen A. Austin

Hernan Cortez

President James K. Polk

Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla

Sam Houston

General Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna

President John Tyler

General Jose Joaquin de Herrera

General Zachary Taylor

President Mariano Paredes y Arrillaga

Commodore David Conner

Juan Almonte

Commissioner John Slidell

General Mariano Arista

Captian John C. Fremont

Mariano Guadalupe Vallejo

Colonel Stephen W. Kearny

Valentin Gomez Farias

Commodore John Sloat

President Benito Juarez

General Winfield Scott

President Pofirio Diaz

Abraham Lincoln

 

Nicholas Trist

 

Ulysses S. Grant

 

James Bowie

 

 

 

  1. Battles/ Army Life

·        This exhibit would have plenty of pictures to display exactly how soldiers lived, and the hardships they endured. I would also try to have a few artifacts. To bring out the past.

·        I would list the battles, and have a movie to watch, a 3-D interactive movie so you can feel the bullets pass by your face, and horses galloping around you. This movie would be interesting, enjoyable, and educational.

 

  1. Aftermath

·        This part of the exhibit would just explain what happened after the war.

·        The advantages and disadvantages of the war.

·        How the war affected people.

·        Explain the changes after the war.



__________________
Kelby

Date:

DBQ

 

 

The western migration grew rapidly after 1820 and it had an influence on the social economic and political trends of the rest of the country.  First of all there was land to claim and money to be made so many individuals decided to make the long hard journey westward.  California was talked about in newspapers as a place with good soil and good climate with economic opportunity.  An article in The Saint Louis Weekly Reveille describes it as a perpetual spring with a soil unsurpassed for richness and, a prize for industry.  The article further tells people that the gold, silver and precious gems that the earth is holding in its flinty bosom are available without the cost of labor and expense.  With the migration there was the need for railroads and Document H show how the addition of railroads started to increase after 1820 and that increase continued with well over 15,000 miles of track being added by 1870.

 

In addition to the economic changes there were many social changes.  The Indian population was again in the way and was now being moved to small areas called reservations.  Document E tells us the each tribe will receive a permanent home with well defined boundaries.    The document tells us that all of the Indians are expected to remain in their designated area and the food shelter and clothing will be provided for them as well as facilities for education and religion.  With the addition of the railroad Document A shows us that a new group of people are immigrating to the United States, The Chinese. They can be seen in the picture as laborers building the railroad.  Another social issue that was created due to westward expansion was the issue of Mormonism.  Document G that there was at the time a Crusade against the Mormons.  It appears that the campaign was designed to take the attention away from the Kansas Crisis.

 

The Kansas Crisis is a social as well as a political issue. The problem with westward expansion is whether the new areas should be slave states or non slave states.  This problem started with Kansas and it caused division among the non slave and the slave states.  Document J is a piece written by David Wilmot against slavery in California.  He states protect the integrity of free territory against the aggressions of slavery.  Fundamental law which prohibits slavery in California will be in force.  Document F on the other hand shows that some were in favor of carrying slavery westward.  Senator David Atchison of Missouri writes, we are playing for a mighty stake.  The game must be played boldly, if we win, we can carry slavery to the Pacific Ocean.  He also writes that this issue will result in a fight and that victory will go to the side that is stronger. 



__________________
Kelby

Date:

The Mexican American War was a major victory in the completion of Manifest Destiny but not all Americans were happy with the expansion.  The dream of having the United States boundaries extend from the Atlantic to the Pacific Ocean was realized after the United States was victorious over Mexico.  Although the expansion was positive in the eyes of many Americans there were others who were unhappy with the results.

 

            The term Manifest Destiny is a term used to describe the feeling of many Americans that the United States was destined to expand its borders west to the Pacific Ocean.  It is a term used to express the feeling that it is Gods will and destiny that the United States should expand its western border.  The 1872 painting by John Gast, is a good illustration Manifest Destiny.  The picture has a female angel hovering over the western territory moving in a westerly direction following chasing out wild animals and Native Americans and overseeing the movement of railroads and wagons with white settlers to the area.

 

            John Polk was very much in favor of expansion and one of his first acts once he was sworn in as President of the United States was to force a war with Mexico to fulfill Manifest Destiny. President Polk believed that the border between Mexico and Texas should be the Rio GrandeRiver and not the NuecesRiver as Mexico claimed. He sent General Zachary Taylor to set up a fort on the banks of the Rio Grande and by doing this he angered the Mexicans and they attacked the fort.  After the attack on the fortPresident Polk appealed to Congress to declare war on Mexico.  His desire for war and his belief of where the border lies is clearly stated in his speech to Congress on May 11, 1846 when he states Mexico has passed the boundary of the United States, and has invaded our territory and shed American blood upon American soil.

 

            There were some Americans who were not in favor of Manifest Destiny and thought that it was just a way of a certain group of Americans to expand slavery.  This can be seen in the Letters of Horace Mann in 1850 when he writes Our present difficulties, which as you well know have arrested the gaze of the nation and almost suspended the legislative functions of Congress, pertain to the destiny of freedom or of slavery, to which our new territories are to be consigned.  David Wilmot in a speech to Congress in February 1847 also questions whether slavery will expand to the newly acquired territory when he asks, we are told that California is our, that New Mexico is ours-won by the valor of our arms.  They are free.  Shall they remain free?  Shall they be homes of the white labor of freemen or the black labor of slaves?

 

            The Mexican American War was a major victory for the United States.  It was a victory for Manifest Destiny.  After the war the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo was signed and this treaty fulfilled the United States dream of Manifest Destiny.  The treaty made the Rio GrandeRiver the southern border between Mexico and the United States, just as Polk and many Americans wanted.  If also further expanded the United States by adding a large land mass which included New Mexico, Nevada, Utah and California and parts of Colorado, Arizona and Wyoming.  The quest to expand to the PacificCoast was accomplished.  The addition of California to the U. S. was also a goal of President Polk and this is seen in his diary writing of October 1845 when he writes, I had California and the fine bay of San Francisco as much in view as Oregon. 

 

            Although the Mexican American War fulfilled the American dream of Manifest Destiny it also created a division among the nation.  Many were satisfied with the results while others were fearful that the completion of the dream to expand to the Pacific Ocean would just mean an expansion of slavery.  So it is fair to say that the actual accomplishment of Manifest Destiny was successful due to the Mexican American War but it was not a triumph shared by all Americans.



__________________
Alexa

Date:

fridays assignment -




Spain wanted to convert the Indians to Catholicism and protect wealthy areas of central Mexico. Many were striving to find silver and gold. Spain also wanted to control its people. Educational, religious, and cultural centers started to be built. Indian cultures were looked at as inferior. Anglo- American rule was slowly taking over Mexican rule. Mexico had severe consequences because of the Mexican war. Mexicans began to be recruited for manual labor. Californias workforce was made up mostly of Mexicans. The Second World War heightened Mexicans political consciousness. Union strikes started to happen in California in the 1960s.

Pocahontas helped bring a certain level of peace between her tribe and the white settlers. Indians living in the Old Northwest felt defeated, had many deaths in their tribes and were coming down with new diseases. Some Indian leaders were against fighting and drinking while others were supporters. Indians faced troubles such as Andrew Jackson trying to remove them from their lands and move them to another location. Native Americans split into two different groups, those who didnt argue with the whites and those who resisted.

__________________
Breanne

Date:

Oregon Trail Project
Family Member 3,
in Alexa and Calisa's Group:

Starting from Missouri to Oregon
I was the oldest daughter, who was brave and optimistic. I was eighteen years old.

The list of items that my cousin should have packed for the journey were washtubs, washboards, flatirons, starch and soap, a sewing machine, and some common food amounts that families would take with them would be 500 pounds of flour, 300 pounds of meal, 50 lbs beans, 100lbs rice, 50 pounds of cheese and butter, and 400 pounds of sugar. They would also need a campstove, their own clothing, cooking kettles, frying pans, featherbeds, and quilts.


It would usually take a family 5 or 6 months to complete the journey. Since our cousin was starting from Missouri, they would follow our trail and stop in every state along the way to Oregon. The most important rest stops would be in safe areas where Native Americans weren't located, so our cousin wouldn't be trespassing on their land. They would proceed, probably with about 50 other families along their way to Oregon, and the people as a group, would be able to combat any threats, or dangers.

__________________
Breanne

Date:

DBQ: Identify the factors that led to westward migration after 1820. How did the rising importance of the West influence the social, economic and political trends of the rest of the country in the antebellum period?


 There were many factors that led to westward migration after 1820, such as the gold rush in California, the availabilty of new railroad jobs, and the free western states.
 Many people moved west after they learned of the gold rush  in California and the "gold, silver, and precious gems that the earth is holding in its flinty bosom." (Doc. E) California also had a salubrious climate, and lacked the chilling winds, most of the other states suffered from. Emigrants found wealth in its forests, and the price of living was low in expense.
 Once railroad manufacturers starting needing people to fill the railroad job openings, they hired the Chinese. The chinese had some small people, which were easy to lower into baskets to insert dynamite into mountains. (Doc. A) They also appreciated earning $5, instead of the $3 they were used to raising at home. These peoples worked twenty-four hours a day, and much of the time during winters and snow storms.
 Free slaves were at high risk of being captured and either being sold back into slavery, or into slavery. Since this was legal, they needed to find somewhere safe they could go. Since they saw Kansas as a safe state, many free blacks emigrated there. It was stated that the government would compete with the free slaves for the state of
Kansas, and whichever side had the stronger fight would have their way. (Doc. F)
 In conclusion, many important factors led to the span of westward migration in the antebellum period, such as the gold rush, the fight for free states, and the availabiliy of railroad jobs.



__________________
Breanne

Date:

Students will examine the letters, diaries and documents associated with westward expansion with a particular focus on Mexican Americans and Native Americans.  Students will use the materials available from the Digital History website for their research materials.  Using the tools of historiography, students will make educated inferences concerning the events and issues of the 1840s.

Native Americans Discover Europeans

William Wood

When white men first came to America, they never properly acquainted themselves with Indian tribes, therfore the Indians never became friendly and trusted them. The white people never told the Indians about their way of life, and never acquainted them with their belongings. "They took the first ship they saw for a walking island."
This started the relationship between Native Americans and whites off badly. As with the was things were in the 1840's, Native Amercans neber learned to be comfortable around white men, and didn't know how to make agreements with them over land. If the white people had gotten to know the Native Americans when they had first come here, both groups of people would have been able to coexist peacefully within the same lands.



__________________
Chris

Date:

Mexican War Exhibit:

Group 1: Will be conscripted into the Mexican army and will go to one half of the exhibit. The group will explore:

Mexican and U.S. diplomatic and military strategies used by the army

Giant interactive map of Mexican military units in relation to the U.S.

Witness a squad of Mexican Soldiers performing military maneuvers and witness them load, fire a (blank) shot and reload.

Mexican and U.S. foreign and domestic policies prior to the war

Interactive biography of Antonio Lopez de Santa Ana tracing his rise and fall from power.

Huge circular showcase of weaponry, uniforms, and field gear used by both the U.S. and Mexico

Group 2: Will play the role of American citizens looking at the war from the perspective of the home front (of U.S. and Mexico) The Group will explore:

The daily life of a civilian affected by the war on both sides

Effects and opinions of the war on people of different races

What life was like in cities like Washington D.C., New York, Los Angeles, San Antonio, and Mexico City during the war.

Propaganda from both sides

Mini exhibit on spies and espionage on both sides

Huge circular showcase of artifacts from civilians including diary entries, clothing, money and coinage, ect.
Then the groups will switch and (weather permitting witness an actual Mexican War battle (3 times a day)



__________________
Patrick

Date:

Patrick's Museum

In this exhibit there will be a gift shop where people will be able to buy coon skin hats, sombreros, cowboy hats, and other little nic nacs.

First stop on the exhibit is the Manifest Destiny Room. Here there will be an interactive map of the trails leading west with accessable detailed descriptions of the use of each trail. There will also be a real refurbished wagon, where people can enter and take pictures in, that will be stocked with most of the normal supplies brought on a trip westward. Flash photography is allowed.
 
Next stop is the Hall of Mexiacan Indepence. Here there will be a shrine dedicated to the mexican leader Antonio Lopez De Santa Anna. His statue will be covered with flowers on one half and flames on the other showing the mixed feelings about him. On one hand people see him as an opurtunistic leader who abuses his power and on the others see him as a hero who only does what is best for his country. This shrine will have a button you can press that will have an auditory short biography. There will also be a map of the land Mexico owns and the land Mexico is renting out to Americans with a brief explanation of what rules were required to buy that land.

Now we enter the conflict room. This room is filled with manacans exhibiting the exact opposite behavior required to own the land they bought such as slave labor. It will have plaques with stories of conflict on it and it will also have a section explains why the U.S. didn't join the fight right away and why they later on joined.


The War rooom is the next on our tour. The floor is a map of the mexican territory. This room is big. You will be able to travel to the exact location on the map where that battle took place, and there will be an interative soldier of the army that one that battle and he will describe the battle. At the exit of this room will be a treaty table with a man from each nation on either side and a man dressed up like Nicholas Trist will be selling copies of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo with a slot for you to write your name (Frame sold seperately).



__________________
Dan S.

Date:

family member two must convince him that where you all are living is the place to be.

 

Im George Baumhauer, the father of my family, and my parents were originally from Germany.  I moved to Montana 4 years ago in 1841 and have peacefully settled down.  Im strong and enjoy my work and life here in Montana.  Im a lumberjack and I love the outdoors.  I often go hunting for game like elk to supply the food for my family with my either my two brothers or my sons.

 

Dear Cousin,

            I wish for you to join my family and I here in the grand territory of Montana as it is called.  Here there is plenty of fertile and workable land for you to settle on near us.  There are also plenty of resources to support you here such as the wildlife including your favorite meat, elk.  My family and other people that come around every so often during the year always have a need of your particular skills in carpentry, so there would always be work for you here.  We have also noticed that many other people of German ancestry are moving into this area as well so people of like mind will be near as well.  The climate here is suitable all year round though the winters are cold.  I do implore that you come for we as a family miss you and you would definitely have better life here, which is filled with so much opportunity.

 

                                                                                    Sincerely,

                                                                                  George Baumhauer

 

Facts: The largest number of Germans emigrated to America between the years of 1840 -1900.  In Montana by 1880 Germans accounted for anywhere from 3 to 10% of the population.



__________________
Dan S.

Date:

Zinn Chapter 8 Assignment

 

Who were the opponents to the war? 

The opponents to the war included: some churches, Congressmen, abolitionists, The American Peace Society, The American Anti-Slavery Society, New England Workingmens Association, and some soldiers.

 

How did they manifest (in word and deed) their opposition to war? 

Many of the abolitionists and writers like Henry David Thoreau, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Ethan Allen Hitch**** wrote in essays their opposition to it.  However Thoreau went a step further and physically protested it by not paying his taxes.  There were many churches opposed to it but most that did kept silent.  The congressmen who were opposed to it spoke out against it during sessions in Congress.  Men like William Lloyd Garrison and Frederick Douglass wrote and printed anti-war articles in their respective newspapers and so did The American Anti-Slavery Society also write against it.  The American Peace Society printed a newspaper, the Advocate of Peace, which published poems, speeches, petitions, sermons against the war, and eyewitness accounts of the degradation of army life and the horrors of battle.  The New England Workingmens Association protested it by verbally condemning the war and refusing to join the army.  The soldiers protested it by deserting the army and even taking a position in the Mexican army. 

 

To what degree were their tactics effective?

Ultimately their tactics were highly ineffective and unsuccessful for the U.S. finished and won the U.S.-Mexican War.

 

How could they have been more effective (what were the obstacles in the way of their success)?

They could have been more effective if they had gotten more people to actively participate in protesting the war but in a way that ensured that the soldiers returned safely so as not to deprive them of supplies due to a loss of funds.  What stood in their way was the fact that many powerful people, and sometimes greed ones too, wanted this war for economic gains and used the popular idea of Manifest Destiny to support them.



__________________
Erin

Date:

Zinn, CH.8



 

Who were the opponents to the war? -  As with many past wars there were scores of protesters. Anti-slavery Congressmen, The American Anti-Slavery Society, writers like Henry David Thoreau and Ralph Waldo Emerson, ministers and their churches, The American peace society and even working class citizens (most notably The New England Workingmen Association) all advocating against the war. How did they manifest (in word and deed) their opposition to war?   - There were numerous ways people spoke out against the Mexican war. There were rallies and demonstrations in large cities such as Boston and New York, newspaper articles arguing against the war, famous writers and Transcendentalists wrote essays in disagreement with it, as did many of the afore mentioned associations.  To what degree were their tactics effective?  - Their tactics served to sway some public opinion but it exclusively stop or delay the war. The government was still eager to fight with the prospects of gaining a nice chunk of land that they werent going to let a few rallies and demonstrations stop them. So, no, their tactics were not entirely effective.  How could they have been more effective (what were the obstacles in the way of their success)? 

- In my opinion there wasnt much else they could have done to prevent the war. Whether they liked it or not the government was set on expanding westward and if that meant a war with Mexico then thats what they were going to have to do. I guess there are ways to be more effective, even if not entirely so. They could have tried to sway more people in their favor especially those in Congress. If they had been successful in convincing Congress then they could have prevented the war. The idea of Manifest Destiny however was in the back of everyones mind, especially those who held a title in government. So ultimately their biggest obstacle was the government itself.



__________________
Erin

Date:

Zinn, CH.8

Who were the opponents to the war?
 -  As with many past wars there were scores of protesters. Anti-slavery Congressmen, The American Anti-Slavery Society, writers like Henry David Thoreau and Ralph Waldo Emerson, ministers and their churches, The American peace society and even working class citizens (most notably The New England Workingmen Association) all advocating against the war.

How did they manifest (in word and deed) their opposition to war? 
- There were numerous ways people spoke out against the Mexican war. There were rallies and demonstrations in large cities such as Boston and New York, newspaper articles arguing against the war, famous writers and Transcendentalists wrote essays in disagreement with it, as did many of the afore mentioned associations.

To what degree were their tactics effective? 
 - Their tactics served to sway some public opinion but it exclusively stop or delay the war. The government was still eager to fight with the prospects of gaining a nice chunk of land that they werent going to let a few rallies and demonstrations stop them. So, no, their tactics were not entirely effective.

 How could they have been more effective (what were the obstacles in the way of their success)?
 

- In my opinion there wasnt much else they could have done to prevent the war. Whether they liked it or not the government was set on expanding westward and if that meant a war with Mexico then thats what they were going to have to do. I guess there are ways to be more effective, even if not entirely so. They could have tried to sway more people in their favor especially those in Congress. If they had been successful in convincing Congress then they could have prevented the war. The idea of Manifest Destiny however was in the back of everyones mind, especially those who held a title in government. So ultimately their biggest obstacle was the government itself.



__________________
mre

Date:

grades updated 11/14/07

__________________
Anna :)

Date:

As a museum curator, I would split this exhibit into four parts:

Parts one and two would be two separate halls, side by side. The first hall would give a brief overview of what the U.S. was going through before the US/Mexican War. This would include the U.S.s ideas and beliefs on Manifest Destiny, the Indian Removal, and its expansion westward before the war. The second hall would give a quick summary about what had happened in Mexico before the US/Mexican War. The hall would include the Mexican War against Spain and Mexicos attempt to have a greater population. Both of these halls would also give insight on the tensions between the U.S. and Mexico before the war. Artifacts, pictures, paintings, and written documents will be on display to portray these two halls.
The two halls will join and open up into a large room which will be where the third part of the exhibit is located. In this large room will be where information on the US/Mexican War will be located. From the Battle at the Alamo to the Battle at Goliad till the end of the war at the Battle at San Jacinto, the war will be portrayed though pictures, paintings, artifacts, items of clothing and real life sculptures of the people involved in the war.
This large room will open up into a slightly smaller room, which will be the fourth part of the exhibit. This room will portray the aftermath of the war. This includes documents stating Texass independence, the Treaty of Guadeloupe Hidalgo. Maps will be hanging from the ceiling to show how much land Mexico lost and the U.S. gained from the outcome of the war.


__________________
Anna :)

Date:

Zinn Chapter 8: We Take Nothing by Conquest, Thank God

1. Who were the opponents to the war?

The Whig Party and Abraham Lincoln were opposed to the war but they didnt refuse to pay war funds. Antislavery congressmen, The American Anti-Slavery Society, and Henry David Thoreau were all very opposed to the war. They felt it was a war that was only being fought to eventually extend slavery. Ralph Waldo Emerson also agreed with the opposition of war but didnt protest or do anything radical against it.

2. How did they manifest (in word and deed) their opposition to the war?

They had rallies and demonstrations, wrote newspapers displaying their displeasure, and refused to pay taxes supporting the war.

3. To what degree were their tactics effective?

Their tactics were effective to a certain degree. Rallies and demonstrations increased, as did the publishing of newspapers denouncing the war. Also, enlistment in the war started dropping rapidly. But even with all of this, the war proceeded on.

4. How could they have been more effective (what were the obstacles in the way of their success)?

Some of the obstacles included the Whigs joining the Democrats in the Senate concerning the war measure. Congress could have also overruled Polks war measure if there were more people against the war. Also, all of the opposition should have been concentrated in the north.




__________________
Patrick

Date:

Zinn Chapter 8: We Take Nothing by Conquest, Thank God

1. People who opposed the war included  The American Anti-Slavery Society, antislavery congressmen, Henry David Thoreau, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and many working class citizens.

2. They had many non violent forms of protest such as writing Newspapers essays, forming rallies, and not paying taxes that supported the war.

3. The tactics used made many people of the public against the war. However, it did not sway the government. The war still continued.

4. They were pretty effective in swaying the public but one of their main obstacles was the government. They used all the legal forms of protest which are only effective to a certain degree. I believe that in most cases the only way to make a big impact is with violence. Sticks and stones can break the governments bones but words can rarely sway it. (I think im guna copyright that.)

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard